Jump to content
North Side Baseball

Recommended Posts

Old-Timey Member
Posted
Seems odd. He had good numbers at AAA. Why did they give up on him?

Because he was a 30 year old in AAA and they didn't have a dire short-term need for him.

Posted
Yes, the plan is to trade Dempster. Germano can start.

 

I take this as an indication that whoever is coming back is either a position player or definitely not going to make the majors this year.

 

Of course, I could be reading too much into this

Verified Member
Posted

Makes sense... he's got some experience and is pitching better in AAA than most of our other options.

 

We can roll him out there and see what he's got without burning options on people who won't be ready.

Posted
Yes, the plan is to trade Dempster. Germano can start.

 

I take this as an indication that whoever is coming back is either a position player or definitely not going to make the majors this year.

 

Of course, I could be reading too much into this

 

No. Even if we trade for a pitcher who is major-league ready he won't be in St Louis in time to start - if he has five days rest. If he had less than 5 days of rest, then he certainly would not be able to start. This is solving the issue of having a starter - nothing more. They may not anticipate trading Dempster for a non-major league ready starter, but this does not give any indication either way. It's irrelevant.

Posted
Yes, the plan is to trade Dempster. Germano can start.

 

I take this as an indication that whoever is coming back is either a position player or definitely not going to make the majors this year.

 

Of course, I could be reading too much into this

 

No. Even if we trade for a pitcher who is major-league ready he won't be in St Louis in time to start - if he has five days rest. If he had less than 5 days of rest, then he certainly would not be able to start. This is solving the issue of having a starter - nothing more. They may not anticipate trading Dempster for a non-major league ready starter, but this does not give any indication either way. It's irrelevant.

 

Think this goes a little beyond a spot starter tomorrow. If that was all they wanted all they had to do was call up Coleman (which reports are that he on his way to St. Louis). A team with the Cubs record has no reason to trade for a player for a spot start. This has a larger plan in mind.

 

But it could be irrelevant. The speculation is the fun part.

Posted
Stealing a joke that sneaky made in the past... "who is this germano?"

 

LOL. Arrested Development. That show was awesome!!

Posted
Yes, the plan is to trade Dempster. Germano can start.

 

I take this as an indication that whoever is coming back is either a position player or definitely not going to make the majors this year.

 

Of course, I could be reading too much into this

 

No. Even if we trade for a pitcher who is major-league ready he won't be in St Louis in time to start - if he has five days rest. If he had less than 5 days of rest, then he certainly would not be able to start. This is solving the issue of having a starter - nothing more. They may not anticipate trading Dempster for a non-major league ready starter, but this does not give any indication either way. It's irrelevant.

 

Think this goes a little beyond a spot starter tomorrow. If that was all they wanted all they had to do was call up Coleman (which reports are that he on his way to St. Louis). A team with the Cubs record has no reason to trade for a player for a spot start. This has a larger plan in mind.

 

But it could be irrelevant. The speculation is the fun part.

 

All they "traded" was cash. We lost nothing and gained someone who might be just a TAD better than coleman as a SP fill in for the rest of the year. Conspiracy theory over.

Posted

My bet is that he sticks in the pen after a spot start or two. He was pretty solid in 2010 for the indians and hes got to be better than Casey Coleman.

 

Perhaps even more interesting, he broke Mark McGwires little league home run record, threw a perfect game in the international league last year, and also started out with the padres while theo was there.

 

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Justin_Germano

Posted
Yes, the plan is to trade Dempster. Germano can start.

 

I take this as an indication that whoever is coming back is either a position player or definitely not going to make the majors this year.

 

Of course, I could be reading too much into this

 

No. Even if we trade for a pitcher who is major-league ready he won't be in St Louis in time to start - if he has five days rest. If he had less than 5 days of rest, then he certainly would not be able to start. This is solving the issue of having a starter - nothing more. They may not anticipate trading Dempster for a non-major league ready starter, but this does not give any indication either way. It's irrelevant.

 

Think this goes a little beyond a spot starter tomorrow. If that was all they wanted all they had to do was call up Coleman (which reports are that he on his way to St. Louis). A team with the Cubs record has no reason to trade for a player for a spot start. This has a larger plan in mind.

 

But it could be irrelevant. The speculation is the fun part.

 

All they "traded" was cash. We lost nothing and gained someone who might be just a TAD better than coleman as a SP fill in for the rest of the year. Conspiracy theory over.

 

Never said there was a conspiracy. just that it was more than a spot start. Seems you agree with me.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The North Side Baseball Caretaker Fund
The North Side Baseball Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Cubs community on the internet. Included with caretaking is ad-free browsing of North Side Baseball.

×
×
  • Create New...