Certainly Dusty wasn't brought in as a disciplinarian. He never had that rep in San Francisco. If anything, Dusty was brought in because he wasn't disciplinarian. Had he been, he would have clashed with Bonds on more than one occasion. Instead, he gave Bonds carte blanche, and it was players like Jeff Kent that clashed with Barry. To his credit, Dusty did appear to do a good job of diffusing those situations. Dusty was brought in because he was a massager of egos -- a Phil Jackson of sorts. One of things you constantly heard about Baker after he was hired was how well he worked with Bonds, ergo he was the perfect choice to manage a Sammy Sosa led team. But, as you said, he didn't do a very good job of handing the 2004 fiasco; and without his supposed strength, what else does he offer?