Is it really "stupid" when Floyd is two years removed from a near MVP-like season? Well, I guess they could still trot out Soriano, Murton, and Floyd until Floyd breaks a fingernail. I don't know if you're being serious, but yeah it's incredibly stupid. Floyd was 26th in MVP voting in 2005. Grudz was 27th in 2003... see my point? Saying that he had a "near MVP like season" two years ago means next to nothing for a guy that can't stay healthy. Next to nothing? If he still has the ability to hit 34 HR with a .360 OBP over 550 at bats, I see no reason not to get him an ample amount of at bats.The dude is 34 years old and couldn't stay healthy last year. Yeah, it'd be awesome if he would reproduce the numbers that he put up two years ago, but it's pretty unlikely to happen. And it's pretty stupid to start him over Murton, who is only going to get better.