I'd definitely say Pittsburgh 2004 was more unqualified. Maybe slightly better wins for that Pittsburgh team (although they didn't have any great wins) but Pittsburgh was also 8-3 and had to go to OT to beat Furman that year. Including the Utah bowl game, Pitt played the 66th hardest schedule in the nation and still had 4 losses! Plus a couple statistics that I know you value, they won 4 of their games by only a field goal and a 5th game by only 5. Plus, their Sagarin far right rating was 75th after the bowl game. 75th in the predictor and still in the BCS! Florida State in 2005 was also more unqualified than this year's Kansas though they weren't as bad as 04 Pittsburgh. to be fair, those teams won their conferences: Kansas won't. Also, that was the year that Miami, BC and Prison Tech left the BE so we had only 6 teams.