It does? Doesn't hurt me. I meant hurts us with regard as players leaving our favorite teams and thus making them even worse. well yeah, except the cubs are going to be bad regardless of whether they resign aramis Since we both agree that will probably be the case if we sign Aramis, is there even a reason to sign him? If the Cubs are gonna be bad with him wouldn't it be better to be bad without him and start a fullout rebuilding mode ala the Marlins? I still say offer Aramis 6/90 if he doesn't take it oh well. The whole point about my argument about money is pretty simple. Teams have to work around a payroll. If a few guys eat up a good portion of your payroll you can't really improve your team enough through free agency. They only way you can 5 players eat up about 75 million dollars of your payroll is if you have a lot of good homegrown talent. You have to look at it this way. If we sign Aramis to 6/100 like he wants that is 16.667 million. We already have Lee in for 13 mil a year. You have to assume Zambrano will make about 15 million a year if we sign him to an extension. That will leave us with another 30 millioin dollars to sign two of Drew, Lee, Soriano, Schmidt, Zito. Then we will have to fillup the other 20 spots on our roster for under 30 million. I just don't see how it is possible to build a contender that way. If Aramis trully wanted to be here and win he would take less money knowing that in order to win he would need all the money we can to build winner. the part about the marlins is asinine. who do we trade to get the type of players that the marlins recieved via trade? zambrano? lee? that's fine, but is hendry really going to do that considering what has happened since 2003? and the money you are talking about doesn't really make sense either. +/- 17 + 13+ 15 = 45 + 30 = 75 million. the cubs were talking early on in the offseason about bringing the payroll to somewhere around 115 million. yeah that leaves us anotehr 30 million to sign two of Drew, Lee, Soriano, schmidt, and Zito like i said. Which would add up to 115 million, which is exactly like I said. well that's still 105, but whatever you win. that still doesn't answer the more important question i posed: how do you rebuild like the marlins did in the situation the cubs are in? and do you really think that hendry is the man to do an efficient job of that? even if you trade lee and zambrano for several studs we would be lucky to get one player that ends up as productive as ramirez is now. why not just pay the man?