I'd like to address this. Of course Aaron should be in the discussion, but is he the best all time? Listen, he had 40 more home runs than Babe Ruth. In terms of raw numbers, he had more home runs. But he also accomplished this in 4,000 more at bats. So is he really the best all time? I mean, its the same with some of these running backs and Emmitt Smith, in my opinion. Yes, in terms of raw totals, he has the market cornered...but he also played much much longer and thus had less "impact" seasons, and not to knock Emmitt, but for all that longevity and consistency, it sure took him a long time to crack those records. It took him a long time mainly because the one who held the record (Payton) was also noted for his longevity. It also should be noted that Smith broke Payton's rushing record his final season in Dallas (13th). Payton also played in 13 seasons. Even without those final years in Arizona, Smith would still be the rushing yards leader and the leader in rushing TD's. He would have still trailed Payton in total yards from scrimmage by a back and total TD's by a RB. Those last two records he needed the season in Arizona to accomplish. Furthermore, Smith's last season in Arizona was nearly if not as good as Payton's last season in Chicago. you do realize payton lost a part of year in his prime because of the '82 strike. without that, i think emmitt would need the arizona debacle to break the record.