So we are villifying him by wanting him to stop sucking and start pitching like the ace he is? Ya sounds like we are real irrational. you've been villifying him from your very first post. And no one said anything about the fact that wanting him to stop sucking is a bad thing. But that yesterday was beyond that. We are going to have to agree to disagree because you arent going to change my mind that there was nothing wrong with what took place yesterday from the fans. I was just about to say the same thing, because I think yesterday was bushleague and classless. So was his performence... hahahahaha. that's a good one. yea z's all out hustle and zeal and passion for which he plays the game is the complete opposite of bushleague and classless. But I know you need to feel justification for the way he was treated by supposed fans yesterday. I don't care about hustle, Zeal, and Passion. I care about results, and the man isn't getting it done when we need him most. It's really that simple. And this simple fact as you put it doesn't mean jack when it comes to whether or not he will produce over the higher leverage month of september Do you put any stock into the fact that his stats over the course of his career in the month of Sept arent very good? Hes had 2 very good Septembers, but only 1 of those were when we were in a pennant race(2004) Other than that his stats in Sept have been really bad. Im asking an honest question here, is that too small a sample, or do you think some stock should be put into it? His career ERA is 3.41. His career ERA in September is 3.48. (Actually I don't think that figure includes his last outing, but still there's no statistically significant difference between his ERA in September and his ERA over the full season). That Sept ERA could be a little skewed though by the fact that hes had 2 years, 2004 and 2002, one a pennant race the other not, where his ERA was way under 2.00 Every other year in his career is over 4.00 So like I said I dont know if its too small a sampling to see a noticable causation, but I think it could be something to keep an eye on. I dont want you to get me wrong, Im not blaming his Sept numbers on his mentality at all, I just really wonder if since he throws sooo many pitches over a course of a season, if by Sept his arm isnt just really worn out.