166 vs. 171 in OPS+ Yes, Kemp was a better defender. I'm not saying Braun was the obvious winner, but let's not pretend that he didn't deserve consideration Sure. That consideration should have been "He was a slightly worse hitter, he played a less premium defensive position, and he missed 12 games." That's the end of the consideration. Last two NLers to lead the league in offensive WAR from an up-the-middle position: Biggio 95 and McGee 85.