The payroll wasn't huge in 07, and is it Hendry fault the team underachieved so much the first two months of the season? He put the same roster on the field in April and May when the Cubs were 7-9 games under 500. Then the team that had one of the best records in baseball from June to the end of the year. When you have a new manager, and a bunch of new players. Sometimes it takes a little while to figure everything out. I know that might sound like a excuse, and the record was still 85 wins. But that year we had two different teams IMO. The bad team in April/May, and the good team from June on, that often played like he did in 08. I agree my comments aren't making this convo go away. So you're making a pretty good point. But it comes to a point when you see a few pages complaining about Aaron Miles and comparing contracts to Bobby Abreu, and I'm just like come on. Plus people can only complain about a move so long IMO. I'm fine with people expressing their opinion, but it can go overboard when there still bashing a move months later, and bringing up other contracts to bash a move again. At some point you just need to sit back and see how the move works out. If Miles somehow hits like he did last year for the next two seasons, people won't be bashing that deal nearly as much. People wouldn't be praising Hendry for months, if he signed Bradley to a 1y 1.5m deal. They would say it was a good signing, great bargin, but after a few days that would be the end of it. When they don't like a move, it gets brought up over and over again. People act like they can see in the future, and already know this or that is gonna happen for sure when their bashing a move. There's a difference in saying they dislike a move, then doing that IMO. For example I don't like the Mark DeRosa move, I expressed that before. But now I'm at the point were I'm just gonna see how it works out. If Fontenot sucks, and the depth sucks then I will be bashing Hendry. After Hendry success the last two years, I'll give him the benefit of the doubt. But If he's wrong then I think Hendry deserves a ton of blame, and thats the time for these comments. Everything you said is correct. I'm a Hendry defender but I understand the calls for shenanigans. I'm praying that Fontenot/Miles+Bradley+Fukudome is more productive over a full season than DeRosa+Fukudome+Edmonds/Johnson. Then again, neither Edmonds or Reed Johnson broke spring training with the Cubs. Even Hendry didn't expect Jimmy E's excellent output last year. I'll give Hendry the benefit of the doubt. That said, I'll be shocked if Miles exceeds a .700 OPS in 150 at bats. That mofo better have the best defensive year of his life.