I agree with this. I know people are unhappy with the team. But the fact is if they brought the 9 guys back that play pretty much everyday and then added another bat and a decent catcher the offense would be top 8-10 in the game. Maybe better. Play 9 guys in 8 positions and then go between Amaya and whatever catcher they bring in. Trade a few young guys for a young starter on the Mariners. Sign a pen arm. The team would have a quality line up, at least one solid bench bat every day, a solid staring rotation and with some luck a good pen. In all honesty this is an 83-86 win team this year. And that is with several very bad losses and without a good PCA for half the year. There is no reason the team can’t be a 90+ win team with the same guys plus what I am suggesting.
Maybe sign one of the bats a tier below Soto, trade for Woo, Kirby or Miller, maybe trade for O’Hoppe, Raleigh or A’s catcher or if all too expensive in the way of prospects, sign a guy to split time with Amaya. There are a few decent semi regular catchers available.