As someone said earlier, the best way to learn about how lousy Macha was would be just to go read Elephants in Oakland. Zachary D. Manprin is pretty much my hero. That'd require a lot of work though, so I'll just throw an example out there. Jason Kendall played 150 games this year. Not many catchers do that. You'd think that the ones who do would be halfway decent. Kendall wasn't. He was reasonable at blocking and catching, but he was incapable of throwing. It was absurd. Also of note is the fact that he didn't homer this year. He had one triple and twenty eight doubles. 29 XBH's in 601 at bats. His SLG was .321. His .345 OBP was nice, but when it was essentially the ONLY skill he displayed this year (besides face first tags at home and scoring game-winning runs on defensive indifference), it doesn't make sense to not give him days off. His numbers don't show it, but Adam Melhuse was a hot hitter at times this year. When this happened, he just dh'ed at best. To make matters worse, every single one of Kendall's 601 at bats came either first, second, or third in the lineup. When you add in the fact that, according to BP, he hit into 11 more dp's than expected (29 total!) and that this number is second in the major leagues only to Sean Casey, the playing time he received and the lineup preference he received appears to be borderline ludicrous. And that's just one player. I could write as much or more on Chavez (needs days off due to sucking), Dan Johnson (why is he batting so low in the order), Nick Swisher (he's terrible for extended stretches, let's see some Matt Watson), Scott Hatteberg (should never play), Barry Zito (does he have to go one inning too many EVERY time out?), Ricardo Rincon (should probably never play, this one is on beane too, get him off the team), Huston Street (why is he pitching with such a big lead? why is he going out for a third inning?), Mark Ellis (why did it take 5 months to figure out that he's awesome and should be leading off?), Kiko Calero (got the Michael Wuertz pitching every day treatment at times) and Kirk Saarloos (5 inning pitcher. deal with it. when he throws his 75th pitch, someone should already be up in the pen). On the plus side, the way he chewed his gum was kinda cool, so I'll miss that.