I'd be really curious to hear from the team side how they'd evaluate someone like James Triantos
On the one hand, he's about 900 PAs into his AAA tenure and still hovering right around league average for total offensive output. Not great.
On the other hand he's doing a lot of things right
- His GB rate, long his biggest issue, is down to a roughly average 43%
- His chase rate is down to just a hair below 30% (slightly worse than average) and his z-swing is way up
- His power numbers are poor but not awful, a ~14th percentile barrel rate and a ~29th percentile hard hit rate
- His contact numbers are great, ~90th percentile
- He is at this point because of his speed I believe he is considered a good baserunner, good defensive 2B, and solid defensive 3B and OFer
- He's still just 23. In an org with a less crowded infield he'd almost certainly be a big leaguer before his 24th birthday
So like when you're projecting how he'll be as a major leaguer, do you take his wRC+ and apply an adjustment (e.g. knock 25 points off)? Or do you take each of his component skills, adjust those for MLB, and try to back into a slashline? Feels like those approaches would lead to very different results