I don't see an issue with Kyle being our #1 starter if he's throwing like this. The problem is that he's the only guy you can feel decent about in a playoff game as currently constructed. Montgomery and Hamels are fine, but not guys you want going in the playoffs, Lester looks broken, and Quintana doesn't look totally broken but there's clearly something wrong. Q needs to get fixed and Yu needs to come back healthy or we're going to have to try and bullpen our way through the playoffs. It's not a death sentence, the Indians (and IMO Yankees) showed it works if you've got a pen like ours, but it's not ideal.