Those detractors have made this season a bit more enjoyable. I love the fact that they were so right about a lot of things (Mancini, Hosmer, Taillon,) but we have basically gotten the 95% outcomes from others like Dansby and Bellinger, and then plenty of internal improvement to rise above and be a greater than the sum of the parts team. It's pretty clear that this FO deserves a lot of credit for believing in the roster they were building and sticking to their plan, and developing specific unique skills they identified to get contributions from all over the roster. The game-planning has definitely felt like 2015-2016 levels, pitching to Alonso and Robert notwithstanding, and the players deserve a lot of props for buying in and executing at such a high level.
The general impressions of the team between NSBB and PSD were vastly different. On here most of the posters expected a team that would be slightly above 500 and with a couple fortunate breaks, could be buyers at the deadline and on PSD they were damn near locks to have another firesale and be back to square one in the winter. So many times we heard how they would be wasting the best seasons of Swanson's contract and that even the best case scenario from Bellinger wouldn't help the team much.
We'd be rich if we got a dollar for every time that argument was made.