Not if you're only focused on offense, sure. However, by WAR, it surely can. Just last year Swanson and Nico barely had above-average offense and both were top 30 position players. Andres Giminez was a 4 war player with a below-average bat. If PCA plays a full season and hits league-average, he could be a 5 win player. His defense is that valuable, and he should provide a lot of value on the bases as well.