Last 5 years 1.24 WHIP 3.70 ERA 286.2 IP 240 H 116 BB 270 K ...while pitching in the AL East. How is that crappy? I don't know why you only went for his "last 5 years" when all he's got is a 6 year career. Because it was his rookie season and he put up 3 good years after it to show that it was probably just rookie struggles and not a true indicator of his talent. It doesn't matter though, you can look at his total career numbers for all 6 season and they still aren't close to "ass-y" or crappy. At worst, he's been mediocre. If you want to say he's not worth trading for and all that, fine. But when you purposely undersell an average/above average pitcher and call him crappy, it just hurts your overall arguments.