As much as it pains me to say this, Jim Edmonds was better than both of them for the entire time he played. It pains me to read that, because it's patently false. Patently? I don't think so. It's really not even up for debate. His ability to make flashy dives covered up his less-than-stellar range and his arm was average. He was by far the most fun to watch, though. In my opinion, he was inferior to Cameron Torii Jones Crisp I'm forgetting a few others.