I mean, Swanson is 6th in offensive fWAR since the beginning of last year. You can make the argument that a guy putting up a .771 OPS is not a great player, but that's more a statistics/advanced metrics argument. If we're going off WAR, he's a star. You've got Hoerner at 37th, Happ at 51st, Bellinger at 82nd. Having four dudes in the top 90 in a thirty team league is good.
On the pitching side, Steele is 25th since last year, Stroman is 38th, but obviously both are performing much better this year (7th and 10th).
I think this is an above average team that isn't far off from being a Good team, and seems like most people want to blow it up because they don't see a path to being a Great team. Which, maybe? But starting over I think just puts us back in this same spot in like 2 years.