It holds a small amount of weight but not much when it goes against all other evidence. Again I ask, which of those hitters would you reasonably expect to revert back to how they hit from April and May? I'll give you Tucker if he was healthy, which he's not. So four of those hitters way overperformed what was expected of them and the fifth is injured, why on earth should I reasonably expect that offense to return? Is it possible? Sure. But it's not smart to expect the 1-5% end of the bell curve to happen again.
You're making an argument against a point I'm not even making. I'm not ranking the teams 1-30 where there has to be a best team and a second best team, etc, and I'm not talking about how likely they are to advance in the playoffs. The best team in a season isn't necessarily a great team. This season is different than 2017-2023 where they were 3 or 4 100+ win teams. If you have five dudes who are all between 5'-6" and 5'-10", that doesn't make the 5'-10" guy tall. It just means he's taller than the other guys. The Cubs can be the second or third best team this year without being a great team. And I'm not trying to say they're like the 16th best team.
I would recommend scrolling rght past the dumbasses. It's very easy to because I do it most times I venture into a game thread. Or if you can't scroll past all of them, pick the 3 or 4 dumbest of the dumbasses and block them so you don't even see their posts. Also it's a game thread and people are allowed to overreact a bit. Not everyone is a robot like David. And yes, some are worse than others. So block the worst ones.