Because a draft isn't run by one man a few weeks leading up to the draft. It's a collaborative effort in which the GM is like director and starts as early as August of the year prior. I know all of our draft prep starts around the time of the combine but not an NFL scouting department. I just don't think you can discount the relatively short time frame Emery or must GMs have from the time of being hired to the draft with all the other aspects of running a team. Plus add in the fact if a GM uses a different scouting/grading/language system. Which Emery did/does and implemented after the first draft. So properly managing a draft is as much about your management of your team of employees as it is about scouting ability (not to discount scouting because it's still really important, especially being the guy at top with the final word). And anyone who claims to run the show alone is a lying blowhard, sucks at drafting, Bill Bellicheck, or some combination of the three. None of that excuses a horrible pick. This isn't rocket scientist. That same mistake can be made in year 4 as easily as year 1. I'm not interested in excusing the pick if you read my first post. No added weight or to later picks or anything. A failure in year one is the same as a failure in year four if I'm evaluating the job he has done 4 years from now. Just interested in projecting what to expect going forward. Early returns from year two are much better. Time may still show that to just be variance and luck, but I feel pretty good about everything I've ever read about Emery and how he evaluates talent and his background as scouting director. I think some people have a romanticized view of sports GMs as brilliant guys or duds who make or break teams, but the truth is the brilliant ones do a better job surrounding themselves with other talented people and evaluating their opinions alongside their own. To that point, I have to emphasize the shift in added scouts, promotions, and dismissals that occurred after his first draft, particularly the additions. There are resources going to scouting that either Angelo chose not to use, allocated the resources elsewhere (though I couldn't tell you where that could be) or wasn't able to convince the people with the money that it was important. Either way, Emery gets credit for bringing up our scouting department to the level that it was needed, which by many accounts was lacking behind many of the top NFL franchises. So that makes me feel much better about things going forward verse year one.