Do you think he would cost less than Choi or Pena? Probably not, but he has more value when Lee returns than either of those two. Like I said before, if the injury is going to force you into a move, I'd prefer it to be someone who's still going to help you out after Lee gets back beyond a strictly PH role, since none of the options are big bats. Now, if the choice is Pena as a FA on Tuesday or trading for Cuddyer, then I think you go after Pena. EDIT: To expand upon Cuddyer, he's everything that Freddie Bynum's roster spot should be. Can get on base, hit for some pop, and also play all over the place.