I would absolutely LOVE to have Tucker back next year. I think he's the guy who he was if you look across the whole year. His wRC+ since 2021: 146, 130, 139, 176 (partial year), 136. That puts him in the top 15-20 hitters in MLB. He's a positive on the basepaths, but a bit negative in the field.
I don't think that combination at age 29+ makes him worth $300M. A lot of that probably depends on the shape of the next CBA. But it does make him a player I'd really, really like to have for the next 4-5 years. I think I'd ideally like to pull off a Twins/Correa thing. Sign him, get the first few years of the deal and trade him before it's popular but while you can still get someone to take on the full contract.