That is true. However, some Card fans refuse to acknowledge that Rolen's 2004 was a aberration, in probability. He is 31, exiting his prime. In his prime (and for his career overall), Rolen averaged around .275-.280, 25-30 homers. I know he was injured last year, but like Derrek Lee, Rolen is going to have to prove his best year wasn't a fluke. Aramis is just entering his prime, and looks every bit of a .300-.310, 35-40 home run guy. ARam had his first .300 AVG, 30+ HR season at age 21, the same age Rolen was when he broke into the majors. Since then, Aramis has had 2 more such season (even though one was significantly shortened by injury). I think when you factor in defense, Rolen is more valuable overall right now. But Ramirez is the better offensive player. Having said that, David Wright may well end up being better than both of them, perhaps as soon as this year.