Wow, that's ridiculous. Not really. You're telling me that since there were 15 balls hit into play for Verlander and all of them were recorded as outs aren't lucky? There were 9 balls hit into play for Escobar and only four of them were recorded as outs. You tell me which player is more likely to have success. Yes, and how hard and where the balls were hit don't matter. You're right. A pitcher has NO CONTROL on the directional vector of a batted ball. To argue otherwise is to be stupid. How hard? Probably, BUT most hits aren't the hardest contact off of bats. Most hits are looping liners or groundballs through the infield -- hardly hot shots. So a pitcher can't induce balls to be batted to the opposite field by pitching on the outer half, or vice versa? Or induce more ground outs by throwing stuff that breaks down and in, or fly balls by throwing stuff in, up and on the hands, or rising heat? I didn't say a pitcher couldn't change the trajectory of a ball up or down. Groundballs actually wind up as hits much more often than flyballs, like three times as much, and today 11 of the 15 balls in play were of the groundball variety. Sure a pitcher can induce a ball to a certain side of the field, but he doesn't have control on whether it goes right to the shortstop or two feet beyond his range. ALL of that is pure luck. Well, if you can induce a weakly hit ball in the direction you want (say in the direction of Perez and Polanco), then you have given yourself a good chance of getting an out. A combination of factors largely controlled by the pitcher. Sure, there is a huge element of luck in involved, but to say it is all luck just doesn't jive. If Verlander doesn't have his best stuff, maybe the grounders aren't hit as hard, or he misses over the heart of the plate and a grounder goes up the middle instead of at the SS. Or if he misses up or down, grounders or fly balls turn into line drives. Or if he isn't on his game, the balls are hit harder, etc. The fact that Escobar gave up 5 hits and 3 runs while Verlander gave up nothing is not a function of pure luck. Some luck, but not nearly all.