It was definitely a "win now" move. The downside is that if they don't win now, it could backfire pretty badly. The Brewers went from having a top farm system to maybe the thinnest in the game in the past few seasons. Fielder will walk after 2011, with Greinke almost certainly following suit after 2012. After that year, they may well have one good SP and holes in CF, 2B, C, SS, RF and 1B. Mat Gamel will probably fill 1B, but he's no Fielder. They traded away their SS as well as their top prospects at CF and 2B and top pitching prospects as well. They could be holding onto the fool's hope that winning in 2011 will influence some to stay, but it's a gamble either way. But given that the Brewers' time with all those lauded prospects could pass with nothing really to show for it a distinct possibility, I think it's a move Melvin had to make.