Campbell is a good QB. Not great but he was headed in that direction. McNabb is still a very good QB but likely headed down. He will have to learn a new system which I believe he hasn't had to do in a real long time plus won't have as good of a receiving core, not that Phily's is that great. If you look at the stats Campbell is close to as good as McNabb at this point. QB rating isn't the greatest but McNabb is only 3.9 better over the last two years than Campbell (89.2-85.3) and Campbell is the much more accurate QB. So basically they are giving up a 2nd rd pick in a loaded draft and a 3rd or 4th next year for a QB maybe a little better than their current one. Add in that McNabb is much older, likely to decline soon, a big salary and the fact that McNabb can walk next year leaving the Redskins with no QB and I say this trade was a bad one for the Redskins and it is not particularly close. I hadn't realized how close Campbell's stats were to McNabb's. I wonder how much better McNabb fits Shanahan's scheme than Campbell does. I know Shanahan likes mobile QBs (Elway, Plummer, Cutler) and I wonder if he felt like McNabb would fit the offense better (because of better mobility)? Campbell isn't Peyton Manning slow, but I believe McNabb is more mobile.