Yeah the quality of the opposing pitches dictates how well a batter can do. If you put every pitch into the same quality catagory, you'd be in a fantasy world. It doesn't work that way. Sure, he didn't get the job done, but that doesn't erase how, why, or what took place to get that result. Similar to telling me that a hitter went 2-4, that doesn't tell me enough as how good did he do. The <1.000 OPS is good statistically but did he hit 2 line drives or 2 seeing eye singles or something in-between?