Abreu is much much better offensively, it's not close. And he's has greater value relative to the Cubs needs. I disagree since we also need to look at the end result following a deal. For instance, with no decent free agents at SS or 2b, trading for Abreu leaves us with Abreu, Cedeno, and Perez. Trading for Tejada still gives us the room to obtain Jones with an end result of Tejada, Jones and Cedeno. Tejada, Jones, and Cedeno > Abreu, Cedeno, and Perez. Plus, that's a younger team with a brighter future. I get the feeling Abreu is at the end of his prime years. First off, we would still have Walker and Hairston. The idea of Cedeno, Neifi/Hairston/Walker, Abreu is much more productive than Tejada, Cedeno, Jones. Secondly, Tejada is going to be in his age 30 season this year. So, while 2 years younger than Abreu, he's not all that young either. Finally, I think Tejada has four years left on his contract, compared with Abreu's two remaining years. That would give the team more flexibility in the short term.