Here's my take on Maddux: 1) Considering that it's almost August 1st and we're more than halfway through the season, I'd have to believe Maddux has taught guys like Marmol, Marshall, Guzman, and Ryu a fair amount by now. Maybe he hasn't taught them everything he knows, but he's likely taught them enough to last them a lifetime during these past months. With only two months left to go in the season, how much more can Maddux really teach these guys? 2) While I appreciate the job Maddux has done with these younger pitchers...it should fall on the pitching coach to be the main source of help and coaching for these guys. You hear them all talk about how helpful Maddux has been, but how often do you hear them talk the world of Larry Rothschild? Shouldn't Larry be the one teaching these guys more than Maddux? Doesn't that just speak really poorly for Larry, or am I missing something? 3) The Cubs are incredibly far out of contention. There's no bleeping way they're going to make the playoffs this year, much less get to .500. From here on out, the only reason veterans will get playing time over promising rookies is for the coaching staff to pad its resume. Unfortunately for guys like Hill, Ryu, and Guzman, Maddux is taking up a spot in the rotation that could be valuable for their development time. While Maddux's coaching can definitely help them, the best way for them to learn is through experience. 4) If it's true that teams like the Padres, Giants, and Dodgers are after Maddux and are willing to fork over a good prospect or two for him, why not trade him? This organization lacks position prospects who could seriously vie for a starting spot out of spring training next season. Pie's got a bright future, but he needs more time in AAA to work on his plate discipline and base stealing. Theriot, Fontenot, Hoffpauir, and McGehee could all end up being good bench guys, but they are nowhere near the level of guys like LaRoche, Kemp, and Kottaras. We all know how much help this offense needs, so why not address it? 5) Along that same vein, one of the daunting problems coming into this offseason will be the acquisition of a starter. The Cubs need a reliable and competent guy in the #2 slot. Wood might come back at a reduced price, but can he be trusted? Maddux might come back again, but can he put up the numbers the Cubs need? Will guys like Guzman and Marshall be able to remain healthy despite their injury histories? Will Marmol and Hill be able to gain better control and command? Maddux (and/or Ramirez) could potentially fetch that from another team. He's done a terrific job with the Cubs and I'd love to see him return as a pitching coach after his playing days are over. But right now, he's most valuable to the Cubs as a trading chip for a team looking to overpay for a starting pitcher.