at least for caridad, that umpire did a reasonably good job: http://www.brooksbaseball.net/pfx/index.php?month=4&day=9&year=2010&game=gid_2010_04_09_chnmlb_cinmlb_1%2F&pitchSel=534428&prevGame=gid_2010_04_09_chnmlb_cinmlb_1%2F&prevDate=49 That's actually pretty nifty. However, I think it helps prove my point. I'm going to focus on this chart, which charts Caridad's pitches to RH hitters. MLB Play by Play in the bottom of the 8th, specifically the Johnny Gomes AB is what I'll be looking at. If you look at the chart, there are two strikes called on the outside corner on 1st and 2nd pitches, including the first pitch that was a decent bit outside the zone. Those were the first two pitches of the Johnny Gomes AB, which had Gomes down 0-2. I think the problem for that particular sequence was that there was an expectation that Caridad could get away with working the outside corner and getting certain outside pitches called strikes. Unfortunately, I think Caridad and whoever was calling that pitch had an expectation that Caridad would continue getting that call, which turned out to be an incorrect assumption. For whatever reason, I don't think anyone on the Cubs' side got the picture until Stubbs went yard. The ump corrected himself and ended up calling that corner correctly following strike one to Gomes, don't get me wrong. Caridad shouldn't be complaining about it. However, I can see how Caridad thought some of those pitches should have been called strikes.