I still trust them to develop bats decently. They have also traded away Eloy, Gleyber, Jeimer, and Jorge (maybe forgetting someone) but they largely developed those guys outside of the main core. Plus developed Vic, Nico and Bote in the last 2-4 years. And there’s enough bats the prospect guys seem to like it seems like they’re doing a decent job (you don’t hear prospect guys say they like Brennan Davis as an example but don’t like he’s in the Cubs hands). Strumpf and Amaya seem close to being something at the ML level too. All those guys you mentioned were either IFAs, drafted by another team (Vic), a 1st round pick (Nico) or in Bote's case, virtually the only player drafted after the 1st round under Theo that has produced any positive WAR. But in that case maybe the issue is identifying talent in the draft rather than developing that talent. Or its just a weird anomaly that the Cubs have had above average success developing IFAs, 1st round picks and other team's draft picks while having extremely below average success developing draft picks taken after the 1st round. List of (I think) every player to accumulate major league WAR with the Cubs that was taken after round 1: 2011: 14 - Maples (-0.6) 16 - Raul Lopez (0.2) 2012: 2 - Underwood (0.0) 18 - Bote (3.3) 2013: 2 - Zastryzny (0.2) 2014: 3 - Zagunis (-0.1) 7 - Norwood (-0.2) 2015: None 2016: 4 - Tyson Miller (0.0) 2017-2020: None Excluding Bote, the rest of the Cubs non-1st round draft picks since 2011 have yielded a combined -0.5 WAR for the Cubs. Anyways, I'm getting off topic. This is "look at this mildly interesting stat I uncovered all by myself" more than anything.