I have no idea what your first sentence means. As for the rest, he isn't relatively consistent from year to year. He was very pedestrian in 2009. He is coming off a career year. The vast majority of these guys are not consistent every year, and that is the reason you don't sign him. Plus, the consistent ones don't walk a million people a year. If Marmol does what he did this year for the next two years, then go ahead and think about a longer term deal. But there is just no reason you sign him now unless he is offering an insance discount just for the security. It has nothing to do with taking line drives off the elbow, it's all about the inconsistency of relievers and his ridiculously injury inviting motion. Sorry about the first sentence. I meant how many years is Marmol away from FA right now. My head is in a daze thinking about how I'm gonna miss the Bears game tonight. While technically you were right, in 2009 Marmol was less than consistent vs. the other years of his career. But if a 1.5 WAR is pedestrian and thats his FLOOR, well then I'm fine with that. In the last 4 years only Marshall (10 - 1.9), Wood (08 - 1.8) and Marmol (07 - 2.8, 08 - 2.2, 09 - 1.5, 10 - 3.0) have had seasons out of the pen with a higher than 1.5 WAR. I'm perfectly fine with Marmol getting a 4 year, $20 mil deal to keep him on the team for the next 4 seasons.