Totally an agree to disagree type thing. I don't mind your arguments, I just feel different. Also CFB would still be a sport where one game can change the season, its just different teams that one game can change everything for. Well, not really. With 8 everyone has a mulligan. With 4 you probably have a mulligan, but you'd better play a really good team out of conference (Oregon), dramatically improve following the loss (Oregon and Ohio St) or play in a great conference where you can rack up quality wins (Alabama). Like you said right now you have a mulligan if you lose so its not "one week can change anything". Ohio State looks like one of the best teams in the country and almost didn't make it because their freshman QB was starting his first game against P5 competition and lost. If they beat Wisconsin 38-0 instead of 59-0 they might not have a shot this year. Anyways, we could go on and on forever, agree to disagree :D