I guess I have to say it one more time so we all know - Bonds would have been a Hall of Famer before he took steroids. I made that clear from the beginning. But he would not have been the best ever without PED's and I think his career numbers make him the best hitter, if not the best player ever. Someone who went to the level Bonds went to juice and cheat out of sheer jealousy - maybe an unprecedented level of juicing (the repeat offender ARod is close) and became the best ever only because of that does not belong in the Hall. I prefer a Hall of Fame that isn't tainted. You can say that there are people who are in the Hall who cheated. I'm sure there are plenty, but that in no way means we should allow every cheater in from now on. Once a baseball stat becomes a stat I don't think you can wipe it away. Bonds can keep his fake stats, but he needs to be punished. Staying out of the Hall is what I would consider fair. This is one of the deterrents baseball needs to try to stop the current steroid era. Vance, greenies were not illegal for most of Aaron's career. Even if he took them regularly, I would have no problem with it. All the players had access to them and MLB had no problem with them until '71. And the fact that everyone could take greenies legally pre '71 is the point. Greenies were advantageous and they were legally there for the taking. Post 1991 steroids and PED's weren't. I don't know enough law to determine if your DR scenario is considered legal by MLB, but I find it highly unlikely that a guy dumb enough to use a corked bat only took PED's in the DR. Sammy doesn't deserve the benefit of the doubt. Would they even work well if he was off them during the season and on during the offseason? Don't you need to be on regular cycles?