"way too many holes"? I don't see that as accurate, really. There are several positions where the production is unpredictable due to youth and inexperience (Baez, Alcantara, Hendricks). But there are few true "holes" on the team at this point. (Cue sneaky saying Baez is the biggest hole on the team right now) The OF in general is a giant hole at the moment. The only guy who figures to be a plus offensive player is Soler, and he has a Grant Hill-like injury history (not quite, but you get the point). The CF is a prospect coming off a rough debut who's a career IF - the LF is a mediocrity who's as classic a regress-to-mean candidate as they come. The backup is a guy who probably shouldn't even be in the major leagues. That's a hole. Soler, obviously, needs to play every day as long as his legs hold up (or maybe 5 times a week so his legs hold up). But you could add two starters in the OF without "blocking" anybody, really. Coghlan certainly doesn't need to be deferred to, and playing a season as a super-sub certainly wouldn't derail AA's career. And there's no impact OF who's knocking on the door in the minors, unless you write off Bryant as a 3B. More broadly, the lack of experienced bats throughout the lineup is itself a hole. You're dumping a huge load on Castro and Rizzo here, both of whom are still young and the former of which is hardly a sure bet to succeed. The lack of OBP and speed is also a major hole. There's plenty to choose from, and what this roster needs isn't cheerleaders - it needs players. Gomes is fine as a 5th OF and a PH, maybe a RH platoon with a decent lefty LF. No more than that.