i cant agree. he's great at throwing out runners, and is really accurate for the most part. but he's far too lackadaisical (sp?) out there, and makes too many stupid plays. seems to be a bit on the passive side when it comes to chasing after balls as well. which, considering his injury history, might not be such a bad thing. but you dont ever see him laying out jim edmonds style. edited to add: it sure seems like he threw out more than 4 runners trying to score last year!