You do realize that they'll be signing Fielder or Pujols to more than a 1 year contract right? And that there's not any other elite level 1st basemen on the market in the next few years or near ready guys in the system? What do you propose they do for first base production on 2013-2015 if they don't sign one of them? This isn't about 2012. It's about getting a core of very good players in place to be competitive as soon as possible, whether that ends up being 2012 or 2013 doesn't matter, but you need a big bat in the middle of the lineup to make that happen and those 2 guys fit the bill. Votto is a FA after this season I believe. If we can't get Pujols I would at least think about passing on Fielder this offseason and finding a 1 year stop gap for first base again. Then go nuts next offseaon, with all the money coming off the books, we could sign Votto, Kemp, and Hamels and have a payroll about where it is now with those 3. I thought Votto was a free agent after 2013, but I might be wrong. He is, I messed up the years. Thought he was after this year since the Reds were rumored to be open to trading him.