Have you seen him Catch? Could you or anyone here even tell the difference between an average MLB Catcher, and a below average MLB Catcher by watching on TV? Catching is not an easy eye test to scout, so many different factors come into play (pitchers holding runners on, pitchers missing their zones, pitchers crossing up catchers with wrong zones/pitches, catchers framing of pitches, how often a staff throws nasty sliders in the dirt, explosiveness of a catcher on their throws, arm strength, accuracy, blocking, etc). Nobody here knows what is going to happen to Schwarber, and nobody here has any idea what the best route is for him (staying at catcher, mixing catcher in while he gets taste of MLB, playing another position while getting taste of MLB but still working at catcher, or completely forgoing catcher to get his bat in the lineup). But, the Cubs probably have a pretty deep grasp on what should be done, what Schwarber can potentially do. So if they still think he can play catcher longterm I'm far more inclined to believe them than the fans who want to give up on it already without knowing two things about the position. From the scouts there seems to be an immense work ethic in Schwarber and natural athleticism, coupled with significant improvement since joining the Cubs system. He seems to have the ability to be average to below average defensively behind the plate in the future & even at below average to get that kind of bat production at catcher can be immensely valuable.