It's not me who is putting forward the extreme here. The opposing argument is that the Cubs' current front office took over a team so incredibly awful that there was no point in even trying to field a competitive baseball team and therefore they cannot be blamed when it went incredibly, incredibly wrong. I'm not the one saying that the only relevant information about what they inherited is the 2012 fWAR of players who were on the Cubs in 2011 and project to be in 2013. The Rizzo trade proves my point: You don't need to pay $5 million per win. You can find them if you make smart decisions. They made some, they could have made more. Trades like the Rizzo deal aren't available everywhere. It's not fair to expect him to find all these trades that vastly improve the team's value in one full year. At the same time, Theo probably didn't think it was worth adding significant payroll to try and make the Cubs contender in 2012. They only had one more year of Demp, Sori was coming off an absolutely wretched year etc etc. He most likely didn't think the odds of the team being competitive warranted tying down payroll flexibility.