The Mavs trade was essentially Devin Harris and two #1 picks for Kidd. It was a high-risk, "win now" deal that so far has turned out very poorly for Dallas, and leaves them with 1 more year of a former allstar (Kidd) instead of 4 years of a possible future allstar (Harris), plus the draft picks. Find some other names to plug into a Cubs scenario if you don't like Hill and prospects for Randy Johnson. Maybe the same deal for, say, the 2004 or 2005 vintage Randy Johnson works better. At that time Johnson was still pitching at an elite level, but was clearly on the downside. That's basically Kidd now. Devin Harris and 2 #1 picks...that is pretty bad. Your scenario with 2004 Randy Johnson seems like a pretty decent comparison It would seem right now the trade was awful but it is long from over. The PG runs the team's offense and changing PG midseason isn't easy. Let's see if they figure some things out and gel over the offseason. If they do that the trade won't look so bad and if they make a run int he playoffs next year it would at least be a wash trade. Plus Harris is a bit overrated. Is he a good PG? Yes but he is far from all-star. Especially with all the Deron/Paul's emerging and Rose coming in. He is 24 which isn't exactly extremely young anymore and has played five seasons now. His career high was this season with like 15 pts and 6 assts. Not exactly eye popping stats just good.