they are told what to say about 50% time. At least that's what an NFL ESPN expert that I know has told me. Ellsbury is good but the others are once in a generation type talents Ellsbury is just an all-star caliber player. In other words the others could one day if they pan out make the HoF Ellsbury if he pans out will be an all-star 4 or 5 years. 5 guys taken in the same draft, just 3 years ago, are all "once in a generation type talents"? yes. I said if the pan out. The main thing of what I said was guys like Upton, Braun, etc. have a higher ceiling than Ellsbury. Like I said before if they pan out and get the most of their ability they will be HoF if Ellsbury does the same he is a multi time all-star but not likely HoF. He plays good but not dominant defense, he can't hit more than 20 hr's, compiles a good average but not anywhere close to one that would get him 3,000 hits. The one thing he does better than just about everyone in the league is steal bases. That won't get him in the HoF. Meanwhile Braun could be a 500 HR guy, and 3,000 hit guy. Upton has speed, power, and a very good arm for the outfield. You getting my point. I never said all five will be "once in a generation." Not all if any will pan out but they have the chance to take over for the Manny's, Griffey's, and so on who will all likely be out of the league in 5 years.