I think from a legitimate baseball standpoint you're correct, but from a fantasy standpoint you're way off. Reyes is a good player, but in Fantasy, at this point, he's not hitting for much power, he's not hitting for much average, and he doesn't drive in any runs. He's good for scoring runs and stealing bases. He's becoming no more different than Chone Figgins at this point, a guy who hits well enough, but you mainly play for his steals. He's essentially a two category fantasy player at this point Zambrano and Kazmir, on the other hand, on average, will give you good K's, ERA, decent WHIP, and get you a good chunk of wins with the way both their teams are playing. They can help contribute in more categories than Reyes can at this point. And by adding two above average pitchers, you're essentially doubling what Bedard can offer. Going through with the trade will lose a lot of steals. But Drew is starting to come around and hit well (he's got a 121 OPS+ compared to Reyes' 101) and in the end, Escobar and Drew will produce in more places than Reyes will I'm willing to bet.