I agree that his past two seasons shouldn't warrant that contract. 5 years? Maybe, based on reputation alone... but for that ridiculous amount? Eh, not so much. This is a fun game. It's called Which of these stats belongs to John Lackey and which one belongs to Gavin Floyd. Both are combined stats from 08 and 09 (stats rounded to nearest hundredth of a decimal)... aaaaaaaaand GO! Statline 1: 117 ERA+ | 1.25 WHIP | 4.27 FIP Statline 2: 118 ERA+ | 1.25 WHIP | 4.13 FIP One of those stat lines is worth $16.5 million a year, and the other is... well, Gavin Floyd. fangraphs has floyd as being worth a combined $31.3 million combined over the last 2 years And John Lackey has been considered to be Cy Young caliber while Gavin Floyd is... well, Gavin Floyd. It wasn't a knock against Gavin Floyd, I was making a point that Lackey's media hype has led him to a very lucrative contract where he's expected to produce similarly to guys like Greinke or Sabathia, and instead he's producing like Gavin Floyd. Not a bad thing, per se, but I feel Lackey is vastly overpaid because he's still riding the coattails of his great 2007 when he has been producing at a lower quality while being an injury risk the last two.