Considering that's around league average and his BABIP the following 2 years was .308 in 2010 and .318 in 2011? Yeah. I'd say he wasn't as good as he should've been in 2009 due to a lack of scouting, and the league had continually gotten better against him over the following 2 seasons, mostly because he brings nothing dominant to the table. He pitches in a pitchers haven half the year and pitches to contact and he still has abysmal numbers. That's not a very good sign. You can argue his FIP and xFIP make him better than advertised, but even then those numbers don't jump out at you. Oh, but what does jump out at me are his 2009 FIP and xFIP, you know, the year he was showcasing his talents and it wasn't luck? Yeah, those numbers were 4.77 and 4.27