Billy Beane. Would Jersey Cub Fan? straight up, i'd do it. I might. I don't know a lot about Swisher. His numbers are very solid. He's relatively young and his contract is very affordable. He does a lot of things that the Cubs need done, namely getting on base and hitting for some pop. He's a switch hitter, who handles LHP very well (but not as much the RHP). However, his comparable players list on br.com is a little alarming, with names like Bubba Trammel and Shane Spencer. They are essentially the same age, and I believe when you take Swisher contract into account, they will reach free agency about the same time. Swisher is owed $34.8m through 2012 (if the team picks up 2012 option). Hill is going to start making sigificant money after this season, but team could do well by offering an extension before then. I don't know, I think I'd have to stick with Hill. I'd trade him in a package for a stud, but I don't think Swisher is quite at that level of player I'd be interested in.