I can buy it, although ... I think I'm apt to rank both Underwood and Blackburn over Maples. I've just never been THAT excited about Maples, although it was awesome that we landed him. Here's my question to you - why the big gap from Villanueva to Alcantara? What is it about the 3rd baseman that you like more than the shortstop, by such a wide margin. It is mainly because I'm not sold that Alcantara's bat is real yet. If he continues to hit like he did this year at AA next year, then he will shoot up my list. Though, looking at his BR page, I guess his track record is a little better than I remembered, and I'd be comfortable putting him as high as 10. With Villanueva, at lot of it is SNT syndrome.