You might be right. Then again, Grissom is getting old...fast. He had a huge drop-off last season and that is his most recent performance. It is possible that he will bounce back, absolutely. But most trends continue in the same direction as a player nears 40. Grissom will be 39 in a month. Pagan is 24 and may continue to improve over the next couple of years. Many players don't reach their peak performance years until they turn 27 or 28 (Derrek Lee). Pagan may also not improve, but he has more speed now than does Grissom, will be a superior late-inning defensive replacement, he put up a better OBP last year at AAA than Grissom averaged over the course of his career, and he isn't coming off of a hugely disappointing season last year. That said, I still think Restovich makes the most sense, at this point. Pagan would be a good guy to have in AAA in case Hairston goes down with an injury. You make some good points - keep in mind I'm no fan of grissom. Players peak at 27 but that doesn't mean they are on a linear growth curve until then. the improvement from 24 to 27 is likely to be far smaller than from 21 to 24.