If you change things up and the team starts playing well, would you still put it back the other way just because of weather conditions? The only reason to bat Soriano leadoff is if he truly has a mental hangup hitting anywhere else. If he hits better somewhere else, there's no longer a reason to bat him leadoff. Then let's assume Soriano starts hitting the ball well and whoever is batting in the lead-off spot stops hitting well and it gets into a swing of things that we are in now, and we have no viable lead-off hitter? I'd move Soriano back for a few games and see if he continues to hit well. I will continue to use the example of Soriano not being able to hit well in the #3 and #5 spots while he was in TEX, in a hitters park, in the beginning of his prime years, batting in the middle of a lineup of Michael Young, Hank Blalock, and Mark Teixiera when ALL of those players were putting up incredible numbers Soriano stopped hitting in the 1st spot though, and hit better out of the leadoff spot than in it in 2004. The notion that he can't hit anywhere else just doesn't hold up to logic. He's not really a viable leadoff hitter himself. Compared to the prototypical lead-off hitters, I tend to agree. But he's had plenty of AB's in the 3 and 5 hole to make it a nice sample size (656AB at 3, 618AB at 5), and his averages of .260 and .271 pale in comparison to his .290 at the lead-off spot. I honestly think he'd do fine in the 3 or 5 hole, but he was brought into the majors and primed to be a lead-off hitter, and when Texas took him out of that situation he floundered, and Washington put him back in that position and he had the best year of his career. Like I said, switching it up now and then can't hurt, but I still would like to see Soriano get the majority of his AB at thew lead-off spot, since Theriot is really the only other viable option we can put at lead-off to fit that typical lead-off hitter stereotype, and he hasn't exactly won the starting spot anywhere yet, though it seems inevitable he will. But Theriot is hitting like crazy out of the 2-hole, so would we want to move him out of that spot?