It's a good argument, but I spent my morning making this avatar, so I'll have to reply later. I will say, though, that a lot of it still depends on a combination of Lou's usage of the bullpen, which is unlikely to change, and Marmol's ability to improve as a starter in regards to efficiency. His pitching career is still quite young. I'm also not sure how realistic it would be for the move to the rotation to be made in-season, especially since someone like Marshall is being completely wasted and would be a better option than two starters right now. Piniella probably isn't going to replace both Dempster and Marquis as the season goes on. I would like to reinforce that my original point, though, was with how Piniella uses Marmol out of the bullpen. While I'd still like to see him in the rotation, the main problem is that Marmol is being used at times to eat relatively meaningless innings. And since he's not even the closer, his leverage ceiling is limited right now.