I don't see it that way at all. While it's true that a pitcher can't control what happens to a pitch once it's put into play, that doesn't mean that he's lucky if the defense makes the play behind him. It can mean that he's executing his gameplan perfectly. ML defenders are going to make the plays the majority of the time. Luck is tricky and hard to define. What about the pitcher who misses his location and gets the batter to strike out swinging? That's much more luck than allowing your teammates to make routine defensive plays. ---- Marquis didn't walk anyone today. The point is that pitchers that "pitch to contact" tend to fluctuate wildly in their performance not only due to the defense behind them but because of stadium effects, weather, and pure luck. (Luck constitutes most of it) A pitcher that tends to strike out hitters to get his outs tend to be a bit more stable in their ERA, WHIP, etc. A nice stat though, is that he didn't walk anybody. That and he's keeping the ball in the ball park, and lets hope that continues.